I just did a new podcast with Aaron Olson on the late great Thomas Szasz. Aaron is well-versed in my notorious article, “The Economics of Szasz: Preferences, Constraints, and Mental Illness” (Rationality and Society, 2006). After the article was accepted, but prior to its publication, I actually refrained from publicizing it due to lingering fear of cancellation!
Just an FYI. The Myth of Mental Illness is Szasz's SECOND book. His first book was Pain & Pleasure. Both books were written in "medicalese" style, something Szasz knew well having graduated first in his medical school class, but which he soon thereafter dropped in favor of clear writing.
You're welcome. I'm not sure Tom thought of it as one of his better works. He fairly rapidly gave up writing for his professional colleagues and writing instead to communicate clearly with whoever wanted to read his thoughts.
It should be pointed out that as a matter of strict historical fact, Szasz left Hungary in 1938 at the age of 18 so he never lived under communist rule.
Bryan, regarding your comments towards the end regarding schizophrenia, hallucinations and voices, I wondered whether you had read Julian Jaynes "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" and if so, what did you think of his theory.
Just an FYI. The Myth of Mental Illness is Szasz's SECOND book. His first book was Pain & Pleasure. Both books were written in "medicalese" style, something Szasz knew well having graduated first in his medical school class, but which he soon thereafter dropped in favor of clear writing.
Thanks for pointing this out. Pain and Pleasure was a great book. https://aaronolson.blog/2019/02/02/pain-and-pleasure-a-study-of-bodily-feelings/
You're welcome. I'm not sure Tom thought of it as one of his better works. He fairly rapidly gave up writing for his professional colleagues and writing instead to communicate clearly with whoever wanted to read his thoughts.
I loved every moment of this interview.
It should be pointed out that as a matter of strict historical fact, Szasz left Hungary in 1938 at the age of 18 so he never lived under communist rule.
Thanks Scott!
Bryan, regarding your comments towards the end regarding schizophrenia, hallucinations and voices, I wondered whether you had read Julian Jaynes "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" and if so, what did you think of his theory.
Certainly look forward to listening to this!
Brian I'd be interested in your thoughts on Bari Wiess's recent podcast with Fredie DeBoar on mental illness. Give it a listen
I had a listen. The guest is recommending treatment for non-diseases. He is very confused on his use of language.
It was great talking with you Bryan!