Mark Vaughan, a working economist who has been auditing my Economics of Education class, sent me this email about his experiences in UAE a quarter century ago. Reprinted with his permission. Enjoy!
I enjoyed your posts on the U.A.E. When I worked for the Fed, I served on a team that shared best practices in capital-market risk measurement/management with examiners/supervisors around the world. I typically got to spend two full weeks in a country, and the hosts made sure the team got to sample fully the food, culture, and entertainment during off hours. In January 1999, I spent two weeks in the U.A.E. working with representatives from the Arab Monetary Fund. Even though 25 years has passed, it sounds as if not much has changed. I agree it is a country that works.
Two incidents stand out from my visit. I got my haircut in the hotel barbershop. The barber was from Turkey (which was considerably more open then than today). He and his family were in the U.A.E. on a guest worker visa. We had a nice long solitary chat (i.e., the door to the shop was closed, and no one else came in while I was there). He went on and on about how much he and his family loved the U.A.E. (offering many detailed reasons, so it did not sound canned). I asked him if he missed Turkey’s relative openness. [Just that morning, I had purchased the latest edition of THE ECONOMIST in the hotel gift shop. Stories had been physically cut out of all the copies. When I got back to the U.S., I looked at those issues to find out what had been cut – a story about the U.A.E. and a couple of stories about other Arab countries.] He looked at me as if I had two heads. He said words to the effect of “only an affluent American would ask a question like that.” To him, all that really mattered was the economic opportunity U.A.E. afforded.
Second, (and I wonder if this is still true), I had to go through T.S.A.-style security to get INTO the country. My driver explained that the government takes a very hard line on drugs and pornography, and the searches were designed to keep that stuff out of the country. The next day I went to an internet café to email my family. The place was full of young Arab men looking at porn on the internet. From that experience, I came to understand why many devout Muslims loathe the West. It’s almost impossible to insulate your country/society from “the decadent West.”
Again, I very much enjoyed your class, and I hope to see you in another down the road.
Sincerely,
Mark
People will endure a lot of civil tyranny as long as they have the liberty to put bread on their kids table.
But there shouldn't be a dichotomy.
It's the old Orwell/Huxley dilemma. Is tyranny imposed on us against our will, or do we happily choose it?
A lotus eating society isn't really at liberty. They're tyrannized by their own appetites.
Some pursuits are inherently productive (barbering). Some are a drain on productivity (porn).
Societies are usually a mixture of rightly knowing what to penalize, but screwing up the rest. Porn? Sanction it. Magazine articles? Leave 'em alone.
Whenever someone mentions porn or drugs I automatically think “liberty” and tradeoffs. Good article, thanks.